However, a cplr article 78 proceeding is appropriate where a petitioner raises a challenge as to the taxing authoritys 1 given that respondents were not aggrieved by supreme courts dismissal of the petition, we dismiss their cross appeals. Verified petition pursuant to article 78 of the new york practice law and rules the city of new york and department of index no. Zoning board of appeals of the town of newburgh, decided january 30, 2019, the appellate division, second department, affirmed the supreme courts denial of an article 78 petition challenging the zoning board of appeals determination to grant area variances for a hotel. Oneill, in his official capacity as commissioner of the new york city police department, respondents. Cplr article 78 proceedings and interlocutory appeals during an article 78 proceeding joseph f. Zoning and land use planning joining necessary parties. Public service commission of the state of new york and new york state department of public service, respondents, oral argument requested for a judgment pursuant to article 78 of the civil practice law and rules. Amended verified petition pursuant to article 78 of the new york. Article 78 proceeding law and legal definition uslegal, inc. Verified petition pursuant to article 78 of the new york civil practice law and rules new york county clerks office 19 2012 not compared with copy file mark c. Part b of this chapter explains what you can complain about in an article 78 petition. You can download article 78 petition sample by rightclicking the image of the document above and select save image as. See exhibit a to affidavit of vladimir tsirkin, filed herewith tsirkin affidavit. Accordingly, the supreme court granted petition and remanded this matter to the.
Landlordtenant relations can also be determined in a special proceeding in some instances. Petitioner malcolm harris, by and through his attorneys, martin r. Part e describes how to bring an article 78 proceeding, and the appendix has a sample article 78 petition and supporting papers. Article 78 petition please take notice that, upon the annexed amended petition, verified on april 7. This article 78 petition seeks to vindicate the right of the petitioner the bronx. At this time it is not possible to print the document with annotations.
Introduction a proceeding under article 78 of the new york civil practice law and rules. At ias part of the supreme court of the state of new york. Index no verified petition petitioner the bronx defenders petitioner, by its undersigned attorneys, for its verified petition alleges and avers the following. Part d explains the procedure for filing an article 78 petition. The petitioner would be entitled to a mandamus direction. Article 78 petitions are heard by new york supreme courts,4 which are the trial courts in new york. Some article 78 cases that begin in a supreme court will. The city of new york, respondentdefendant thomas m. Boone v nyc deptartment of education, verified petition. Article 78 proceedings how to appeal an agency decision. Three weeks later, the city moved to dismiss the petition on the ground that the petitioner had failed to name a necessary party within the statute of. The basis of venue is that albany county is the county within which the respondentdefendant commissioner made the decision and order that petitionerplaintiff seeks.
A rticle 78 of the n ew y ork c ivil p ractice l aw and r ules petitioner montgomery blair sibley sibley pursuant to 28 u. New york city article 78 proceedings attorney article. Because plaintiff had only four months to file a cplr article 78 petition against the highway superintendents purported determination, defendant reasons, that same deadline must be imported and applied to plaintiffs factuallyrelated declaratory claims. Denial of an article 78 petition challenging the zbas. Supreme court, civil branch 60 centre street, new york, n. Technically the petition should just contain the facts and allegations with astated cause ofaction, and the. See new york civil practice law and rules, article 78. How to challenge administrative decisions using article 78 of. Supreme court, civil branch 60 centre street, new york. A petitioner may not raise new issues in an article 78 proceeding that were. Cplr article 78 petitions court litigation documents. This action arises out of a march in support of the occupy wall. This petition challenges the boards february 2016 denial of discretionary release and imposition of a 24month hold. Notice of petition pursuant to cplr article 78 index no.
Oneill, as police commissioner of the city of new york, respondents. This article 78 petition seeks to vindicate the right of the public to obtain information about respondent erie countys use of taxpayer resources to fund the countys obstructionist approach to state and federal investigations and legal challenges regarding inhumane and unconstitutional conditions at erie county correctional facilities. There are many different real world types of article 78 proceedings. State of new york supreme court, appellate division third. An overview of article 78 practice and procedure with william h. The person who files a special proceeding with the court is a petitioner. The most common avenue to obtain court intervention is an article 78 proceeding. An article 78 proceeding is used to appeal the decision of a new york state or local agency to the new york courts. See, civil practice law and rules cplr for short article 78. In the labor and employment context, employees who work for state agencies, or municipalities often file article 78 proceedings against a decision from an administrative law judge, or against their employer challenging decisions made about their employment. Simon israel v town of fallsburg, 78 ny2d 194, 204 1991. This court has jurisdiction over this proceeding under cplr 506b1, which provides that an article 78 proceeding against a justice of the supreme court. For a judgment pursuant to article 78 of the civil practice law and rules. Article 78 proceedings how to appeal an agency decision lawny.
Prepare and submit with the petition factwitness and expert affidavits. An overview of article 78 practice and procedure timed agenda i. We strongly recommend that you find a lawyer to help you. This article 78 proceeding asserts the right of petitioner, brennan center for. Challenging a law, rule, or agency decision in an article 78 proceeding can lead to delay in its enforcement, whether or not the suit is successful. An article 78 proceeding is named after article 78 of the new york civil practice laws and rules.
Pursuant to the freedom of information law foil and article 78 of the new. The pleadings are the petition not complaint and answer cplr 7804d, and the parties are denominated as a petitioner and a respondent, not a plaintiff and a. The supreme court granted the petition and awarded the petitioner disability benefits. Petitioners, verified petition for a judgment pursuant to article 78 of the civil practice law and rules,againstthe state of new york division of housing and community renewal, assistant commissioner richmond mccurnin and northtown phase iii associates, lp and north town phase iii houses, inc. Supreme court of the state of new york appellate division.
The best way to learn how to write a notice of petition andan article 78 petition is to go to scroll supreme court recordsonline library and look at different article 78 petitions, especially thosein which the doe is the defendant. Ortiz has standing to bring this claim, the action is not timebarred, as the time to bring this petition commenced not four months from the letter of denial from nycha to petitioners mother in december, 2010, but four months from the date the. An article 78 proceeding is like a summary judgment motion from day one. An overview of article 78 practice and procedure wnylc online. An article 78 proceeding would serve to get a judgment that the petitioners answer be accepted as. Supreme court of the state of new york county of albany x in the matter of the application of riverkeeper, inc. Ldf and the center for constitutional rights ccr, to access public records relating to the new york city police departments nypd or the. Documents in support for leave to amend complaint pdf 108 kb affirmation of pierre ciric in support pdf 465 kb affidavit of theo chino in support pdf 304 kb affirmation of service pdf 373 kb ammended complaint and verified article 78 pdf 610 kb article 78 petition exhibit list pdf. In the matter of route 17k real estate, llc, et al. Part c describes when you can obtain relief under article 78. Supreme court of the state of new york county of new york jonathan corbett, petitionerplaintiff v. Justice at new york university school of law brennan center. Url to the pdf file must be on exactly the same domain as the current web page. For a judgment pursuant to article 78 of the civil practice law and rules memorandum of law on behalf of the commission on judicial conduct in.
1225 623 517 763 1006 639 904 858 1467 617 440 141 958 1221 193 1578 1065 1535 685 981 1571 1173 641 31 1303 782 1143 344 1498 1480 661 1312 142 140 1400 671 758